Wednesday, February 20, 2008

Criminals are wicked nd deserve punishment









According to me i disagree with the sentence because no man by birth is a criminal. Their circumstances force them to do what their heart never wills. Their circumstances can be anything it can be due to poverty, ailments or shortage of food. As in the drama bishops candlesticks the convict steals to save his wife from suffering which he never wanted to do. But there was no way other than stealing. But after stealing as by his luck he was caught. And the punishment given to him was too big for his shoes. This was just an example. Imagine how many people in this world would be suffering like this.Instead of understanding the pros and cons of the prisoner he is chained and whipped behind the bars. After a great suffering in the jail they just convert the criminals into a wild beast. Criminals are also human beings and they need to be consulted.No man is born great and no man is a criminal.They want to get wok but there is no employement for them because of shortage of wealth.
Society should treat them like normal people.They should be consulted and gien a job.People are the future.People should change the world.In this generation by stealing or by lazing around there is no escape.They have to be preached in a certain manner.
By these i conclude that criminals arent wicked and do not deserve punishment.

By
Anjana Ajith
Std. IX

23 comments:

Seraphisbey19 said...

I do admire the statue of compassion,and Impartial aspects
that are voiced in this post.
It denotes good foundation from
the school has been instilled.

aish said...

no information on for the motion

Kunal said...

According to me i disagree with the sentence because no man by birth is a criminal. Their circumstances force them to do what their heart never wills. Their circumstances can be anything it can be due to poverty, ailments or shortage of food. As in the drama bishops candlesticks the convict steals to save his wife from suffering which he never wanted to do. But there was no way other than stealing. But after stealing as by his luck he was caught. And the punishment given to him was too big for his shoes. This was just an example. Imagine how many people in this world would be suffering like this.Instead of understanding the pros and cons of the prisoner he is chained and whipped behind the bars. After a great suffering in the jail they just convert the criminals into a wild beast. Criminals are also human beings and they need to be consulted.No man is born great and no man is a criminal.They want to get wok but there is no employement for them because of shortage of wealth.
Society should treat them like normal people.They should be consulted and gien a job.People are the future.People should change the world.In this generation by stealing or by lazing around there is no escape.They have to be preached in a certain manner.
By these i conclude that criminals arent wicked and do not deserve punishment.

Kunal said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
pranay said...

i also admire the same as you and i also think the same as you

jhon said...

thanks yaar
i have to prepare this for 20 marks
debate section

SIMRAN JEET said...

i totally agree with you

¤¤....@ka$h...¤¤....£övê ¡n the $ký....¤¤ said...

hey i totaly agre with u bcause they r also humans they also want that they should lve hapy and peceful life.

pri said...

i too agree with all of u. criminals too have a human heart

pri said...

I too agree with all of you.

sakshma said...

That depends on your philosophy. Not everyone thinks that it is morally correct to punish an offender just because they "deserve " punishment whatever that means.

Many people believe that punishment should only be administered as a teaching mechanism not out of some notion of revenge. Punishment can include things like incarceration, but also should include programming aimed at assisting the person in not committing more offenses upon release. Things basic education, vocational training, anger management therapy, and substance abuse therapy come to mind.

Punishment by incarceration is not a sufficient deterrent to keep a person from resuming criminal behavior upon release

saurabh said...

thanks u are like alife saver

saurabh said...

u are like a life saver

srilekha said...

i do agree with all of u .but if a criminal is really harmful to the society then action must be taken against him.although thyis should be done after strict investigation.

nibha said...

According to me i disagree with the sentence because no man by birth is a criminal. Their circumstances force them to do what their heart never wills. Their circumstances can be anything it can be due to poverty, ailments or shortage of food. As in the drama bishops candlesticks the convict steals to save his wife from suffering which he never wanted to do. But there was no way other than stealing. But after stealing as by his luck he was caught. And the punishment given to him was too big for his shoes. This was just an example. Imagine how many people in this world would be suffering like this.Instead of understanding the pros and cons of the prisoner he is chained and whipped behind the bars. After a great suffering in the jail they just convert the criminals into a wild beast. Criminals are also human beings and they need to be consulted.No man is born great and no man is a criminal.They want to get wok but there is no employement for them because of shortage of wealth.
Society should treat them like normal people.They should be consulted and gien a job.People are the future.People should change the world.In this generation by stealing or by lazing around there is no escape.They have to be preached in a certain manner.
By these i conclude that criminals arent wicked and do not deserve punishment.



BY
NIBHA.V.M
IXth STANDARD

nibha said...

According to me i disagree with the sentence because no man by birth is a criminal. Their circumstances force them to do what their heart never wills. Their circumstances can be anything it can be due to poverty, ailments or shortage of food. As in the drama bishops candlesticks the convict steals to save his wife from suffering which he never wanted to do. But there was no way other than stealing. But after stealing as by his luck he was caught. And the punishment given to him was too big for his shoes. This was just an example. Imagine how many people in this world would be suffering like this.Instead of understanding the pros and cons of the prisoner he is chained and whipped behind the bars. After a great suffering in the jail they just convert the criminals into a wild beast. Criminals are also human beings and they need to be consulted.No man is born great and no man is a criminal.They want to get wok but there is no employement for them because of shortage of wealth.
Society should treat them like normal people.They should be consulted and gien a job.People are the future.People should change the world.In this generation by stealing or by lazing around there is no escape.They have to be preached in a certain manner.
By these i conclude that criminals arent wicked and do not deserve punishment.



BY
NIBHA.V.M.
IXth STANDARD

nibha said...

According to me i disagree with the sentence because no man by birth is a criminal. Their circumstances force them to do what their heart never wills. Their circumstances can be anything it can be due to poverty, ailments or shortage of food. As in the drama bishops candlesticks the convict steals to save his wife from suffering which he never wanted to do. But there was no way other than stealing. But after stealing as by his luck he was caught. And the punishment given to him was too big for his shoes. This was just an example. Imagine how many people in this world would be suffering like this.Instead of understanding the pros and cons of the prisoner he is chained and whipped behind the bars. After a great suffering in the jail they just convert the criminals into a wild beast. Criminals are also human beings and they need to be consulted.No man is born great and no man is a criminal.They want to get wok but there is no employement for them because of shortage of wealth.
Society should treat them like normal people.They should be consulted and gien a job.People are the future.People should change the world.In this generation by stealing or by lazing around there is no escape.They have to be preached in a certain manner.
By these i conclude that criminals arent wicked and do not deserve punishment.

Shreyanshi Bharadia said...

.. yar guyz! .. can u pepl help me in answering in favour of this! .. i also disagree but due to some FA activity i need to speak in favour of this! .. plzz .. i request help me yeahh !! :)

SATYA DK said...

When I am walking suddenly someone comes and asks me for money pointing a Gun at me, I say 'please I don 't have any ', that Idiut shoots me in the Leg and runs away.

After 2 weeks in Hospital, I fear walking on the roads alone, actually I will never walk again on roads alone.

This person is a Criminal! 'Criminal ' is a person who commits some crime without thinking what consequences may be faced by one who is victim of a Crime.

Should a person like that be Spared? What is the punishment for causing so much suffering to me? Yes, My Friends I am talking for the motion 'Criminals are wicked and should be punished '

A wrong done under any circumstances is a wrong. A poor person who wants to give food to his son will commit robbery or murder, If this poor man murders a young man just for money should he be left away? Who has given him right to harm others because he is in need? Would it not be better if a poor person just eat something from a Garbage can?

Arguments in favour of the motion:
a) Criminals deserve punishment as they are wicked. If they are not punished they will continue committing crime which will destabilize the society. Appropriate punishment will act as deterrent for the criminals to take to the path of crime.
b) If criminals are not punished for their crimes it will be an injustice to the victims.
c) Criminals deserve punishment as they cannot be reformed without being punished.
d) Since the doer of good work is rewarded with appreciation then it follows that evil doer like criminals is awarded with punishment.
e) If criminals are not punished people will not differentiate between criminal and non-criminal activities.

rakha manhotra said...

i agree that no man is not a criminal by birth , he commit a crime due to their circumstances but my opinion is he should deserve punishment because he dont have any right to take the life of some person or even to steal something becoz he dint know that the thing he is stealing would something important for the person

s goyal said...

thax!!! for this information !! i was looking for this information from last 5 days !! thax a lot now i m able to complete my project !!

bharat patel said...

according to my thinking, i totally agree with this statement that they should be given punishment. crime is crime whether it is big or small. the word ''mercy'' never suits them.
i we talk about their circumstances than it can be any, but their solution is not only the way to crime. there should be many ways to their problems. as we always say, ''where there is a will there is a way''. the mercy on them many times lead the path to big crimes.
we cant say that every criminal has a heart and humanity in them if we take example of Delhi case and other such case.
at last i conclude that according to their crimes big or small they should be given punishment.
after many crimes Hitler did, he himself felt guilty and committed suicide but we cant say that he is not a criminal but haves a heart because after such crimes and after world war second, if he feels guilty and committed suicide that has no use.

poorvee said...

thx to SATYA DK